Discussion about this post

User's avatar
True Orthodox Christian's avatar

In Matthew 13:33, the Lord says that the ‘Kingdom of heaven is like leaven, which a woman took and hid in three measures of meal till the whole was leavened’. You lean quite heavily on leaven as exclusively referring to hypocrisy when this isn’t the case.

True Orthodox Christian's avatar

Further, I would argue that the passages from John that you use here are precisely an argument for transubstantiation. The Lord can be taken literally here. The Incarnation of the Lord, and His founding of the Church, can be seen as the point where heaven and earth meet. To put it another way, where the literal and metaphorical combine. Jesus is Word, and therefore He may be understood in a metaphorical sense to be also His teachings, and these teachings are to be ‘consumed’ and ‘internalised’ as you say, but we are also flesh and blood and in order to become one flesh and one spirit (Ephesians 4-6) with the Lord, and regain our eternal inheritance, we must both learn from the Lord, try to follow His example and literally eat His body and drink His blood, which He gives us both literally and metaphorically, although we know that it is under the appearance of bread and wine. The Lord is explicit repeatedly (John 6-50-51). This teaching was hard for the Jews, for the reasons you state, but by the miraculous power of God, who can turn water to wine, part the seas, who has given your body the ability to turn bread into flesh, the bread and wine offered by a Priest of the Faith literally is the flesh and blood of the Lord. I do not deny this is an awesome mystery, but it is the most literal and straightforward rendering of the text, and what is confirmed by the holy Church. ‘Unless ye become as little children…’. - the literal, unalloyed truth, devoid of lengthy and scholarly reinterpretation is surely what we are after here?

5 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?